Engine of Growth

In Defence of Globalisation
Jagdish Bhagwati Oxford University Press, 324pp, £17.99
ISBN 0195170253

Why Globalisation Works
Martin Wolf Yale University Press, 398pp, £19.99

These two books offer a defence of globalisation against its critics. Both cover much the same ground, though with differing emphases. Martin Wolf, a noted economics columnist at the Financial Times, has written the more comprehensive, better organised and (despite its greater length) more concise book. It is a necessary and compelling read for all who want to understand the logic of unfolding events. Jagdish Bhagwati is one of the world’s leading trade theorists. His book has its moments, but he is not at his best. It is intellectually self-indulgent, and his style – with its mixed metaphors (“white elephants making gargantuan losses”), ponderous jokes, linguistic tics and exclamation marks – often seems like a parody of good writing. For this kind of book it is surely better to keep one’s language as unadorned as possible.

Continue reading “Engine of Growth”


Economic development + equality = democracy?

In my last column, I discussed the impact of rich natural resources on economic growth. I pointed out that they can keep a country poor, by slowing down the development of human capital. Today I want to carry the argument further by considering the impact of rich natural resources on the political system, and particularly on the possibility of democracy.

Continue reading “Economic development + equality = democracy?”

Can Russia escape the resources curse?

Most people believe that rich natural resources make a country rich. Fertile lands and abundant mineral wealth are seen as a natural endowment, available to support an abundant life. They also give a ready-made advantage in trade, since food, timber, metals, and energy are universal means to life. Even today many countries prohibit private ownership (as opposed to private exploitation) of their natural resources: in Russia oil and minerals are still owned by the state, though private companies are given leases of various lengths to turn them into usable commodities.

Continue reading “Can Russia escape the resources curse?”

Torture and Abu Ghraib

Western opinion has been outraged by the revelation of torture by US forces of Iraqi prisoners. Photographs and videos shown to Congress (and partly reproduced in Western media) showed American soldiers at Abu Ghraib Prison sexually assaulting Iraqis and laughing over mutilated and abused bodies. Now President Bush has promised to demolish this notorious prison, symbol of Saddam’s police state, which no one expected would become the symbol of American occupation.

Continue reading “Torture and Abu Ghraib”